The AI Emperors have no clothes (but they do have £31 trillion worth of data centres)

Why graduates shouldn’t panic, and why character will probably outlast the latest Silicon Valley messiah.

Every generation gets told the world is ending.

The Boomers had nuclear annihilation.

Gen X had globalisation.

Millennials had the financial crisis.

Gen Z apparently have to contend with being replaced by an autocomplete function.

Frankly, it’s exhausting.

If you’re entering the workforce today, you’ve probably been informed roughly 14 times before breakfast that AI is coming for your job. Depending on which podcast billionaire is currently being interviewed by another podcast billionaire, humanity is either on the brink of limitless prosperity or about to become interns to a chatbot.

The Cappuccino Club would like to gently suggest everyone goes outside for five minutes.

Because there’s an awkward little detail hiding behind all the AI hype.

The maths is starting to look a bit wonky.

The International Monetary Fund recently warned about the possibility of a correction in AI-related asset prices. Translated from Economist into English, that means: “this thing might be getting a touch carried away.”

And by “a touch carried away”, we’re talking about an industry expected to spend something in the region of $31 trillion building infrastructure over the coming decades.

Thirty-one trillion.

For context, that’s the sort of number a toddler invents when asked how many biscuits they’d like.

At some point, somebody has to make that money back.

Which raises an awkward question.

Who exactly is buying all this stuff?

The AI evangelists sometimes talk as if demand is inevitable.

Everyone will want it.

Everything will need it.

Your doctor will use it.

Your council will use it.

Your washing machine will probably develop opinions and start demanding a seat at board meetings.

The trouble is that many AI companies are still searching for something businesses usually regard as helpful.

Profit.

Some of the biggest names in AI have accumulated eye-watering valuations while still struggling with the revolutionary concept of making more money than they spend.

This isn’t necessarily a disaster.

Amazon took years to become profitable.

But it does suggest that replacing the entirety of human civilisation might be slightly further away than some LinkedIn posts would have you believe.

And that brings us to you.

The graduate.

The apprentice.

The young professional wondering whether all those years of education are about to be rendered obsolete by a very confident software update.

Here’s the good news.

Most jobs aren’t really about information.

They’re about people.

And people remain gloriously inconvenient.

A chatbot can generate a report.

It cannot spot that your manager is worried about a project despite insisting everything is “absolutely fine”.

It cannot persuade a reluctant stakeholder.

It cannot build trust with a customer.

It cannot tell the difference between confidence and competence.

For that matter, neither can many executives, but that’s a separate article.

The great misunderstanding at the heart of the AI movement is the belief that work is primarily about processing information.

Anyone who has ever worked in an office knows that work is actually about psychology.

It’s about navigating egos.

Reading the room.

Managing conflict.

Building relationships.

Helping anxious colleagues.

Influencing decisions.

Explaining difficult ideas without sounding like you’ve swallowed a management consultancy brochure.

These aren’t soft skills.

They’re the entire game.

Which is why the Cappuccino Club remains stubbornly optimistic about younger generations.

Despite the doom-mongering, we see a generation that is adaptable, digitally fluent, psychologically aware and remarkably resilient.

These are young people who lived through a pandemic, accumulated significant debt, entered one of the most unpredictable labour markets in decades and still turn up asking sensible questions about their future.

That deserves respect.

And fair play.

Too often society talks about young workers as though they’re the problem to be solved rather than the people who will eventually solve the problems.

Meanwhile some of the loudest voices predicting human redundancy are busy borrowing billions to fund companies that still haven’t figured out who their customers are.

There is a lesson in there somewhere.

Human beings have survived industrial revolutions, recessions, management fads, agile transformations, digital transformations, strategic transformations, and whatever transformation Barry from Strategy was selling last quarter.

We’ll survive this too.

So learn AI.

Use it.

Experiment with it.

It would be foolish not to.

But don’t make the mistake of believing it is the source of your value.

Your value lies elsewhere.

In your curiosity.

In your judgement.

In your character.

In your compassion.

In your ability to understand other human beings when they’re confused, uncertain, difficult or wrong.

And judging by most workplace meetings, demand for that skill is unlikely to disappear anytime soon.

Final sip

The tech bros would quite like you to believe that artificial intelligence is becoming indispensable.

History suggests something different.

Technologies come and go.

Bubbles inflate and deflate.

Markets panic and recover.

But organisations will always need decent people who can think, learn, adapt and earn trust.

The robots may write the emails.

You’ll still be the reason anyone reads them.

Leave a Reply

We ditch the tech jargon and corporate speak, focusing instead on practical nudges and insights to help you and your team work smarter in the digital age. 

If you’re looking to simplify your work life or help others do the same, make it a habit to join us for regular coffee break nudges. Let’s make working easier and smarter a habit, one sip at a time! 

Regular nudges to help you succeed

We know that the digital workplace can be confusing and complex. Nudges are brewed to help you find yourself and realize your full potential.